
Truth and Consequences
Season 10 Episode 6 | 26m 24sVideo has Closed Captions
Telling the truth can set us free, but it rarely comes without consequences.
Telling the truth can set us free, but it rarely comes without consequences. Sarah Kipp embraces who she is and finds a new way to keep her family together; Quentin Lucas chooses conscience over obedience in the Army; and Christina Semple hides her cancer diagnosis from her family. Three storytellers, three interpretations of TRUTH AND CONSEQUENCES. Hosted by Theresa Okokon.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Stories from the Stage is a collaboration of WORLD and GBH.

Truth and Consequences
Season 10 Episode 6 | 26m 24sVideo has Closed Captions
Telling the truth can set us free, but it rarely comes without consequences. Sarah Kipp embraces who she is and finds a new way to keep her family together; Quentin Lucas chooses conscience over obedience in the Army; and Christina Semple hides her cancer diagnosis from her family. Three storytellers, three interpretations of TRUTH AND CONSEQUENCES. Hosted by Theresa Okokon.
Problems playing video? | Closed Captioning Feedback
Where to Watch Stories from the Stage
Stories from the Stage is available to stream on pbs.org and the PBS app.
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorshipSARAH KIPP: Coming out more fully was terrifying.
I was afraid that we'd blow up our marriage, our family, our whole world and that I might still end up alone.
QUENTIN LUCAS: One time, I received a postcard from someone in France who had the poetry in him to write me, "Thank you for taking a step toward a world without war."
CHRISTINA SEMPLE: There was no particular moment when I decided not to tell my family I had cancer.
The truth just always lingered in the background.
THERESA OKOKON: Tonight's theme is "Truth and Consequences."
We like to believe that telling the truth is easy.
It's the right thing to do, it's the obvious thing to do.
But in reality, the truth is rarely that clean.
It can disrupt relationships.
It can challenge identities.
It can force us into making decisions that we never thought we'd have to face.
Tonight's tellers are sharing those moments when the truth faced them and there was no escaping it.
KIPP: My name is Sarah Kipp.
I'm a keynote speaker and executive coach.
I was born and raised in Rhinebeck, New York, a small town in the Hudson Valley.
I now live west of Boston.
I run my own business, and the focus of our work is creating connection in challenging times.
So oftentimes, people are kind of afraid or fearful of sharing their stories.
Where do you find the courage to share yours?
Anytime someone comes up to me after an event and shares with me the impact that my words and my presence had on them, it affirms for me the synergy and the energetic connection I feel when I'm in front of an audience.
It also reminds me that anytime I show up as who I am, there's a chance that that might inspire somebody to share their gifts more freely in the world.
OKOKON: Mm.
- And when that happens, for me, that's the whole point.
That's a really good day.
So what are you hoping that the audience might take away from your story tonight?
Be who you are.
Connect with your own inner self, your glorious, radiant being that has gifts to share in the world.
Share them freely, because by doing that, you also inspire others to do the same.
When my former spouse and I decided to divorce, we did something radical, something we hadn't seen anyone else do before.
We bought a duplex-- together.
One house, two apartments, a shared mortgage.
And we moved forward with our divorce.
We had made it 12 years into our marriage before the volcano erupted.
But the truth is, it had been rumbling for a long time.
Back when we were dating in college, I shared with him with a lot of fear and tears that I felt an attraction to women.
Somehow we believed our love would be enough, that we could get married, have kids, create the life we envisioned and that somehow it would all work itself out.
So fresh out of college, we got married.
12 years in with two little kids, and a whole lot of things not working well in the marriage, I still took my vows seriously.
I was practical; I did the math.
Women usually outlive men.
(laughter) Even if we lived a good long life and we honored our vows and death really did do us part, there was still a chance I could date women someday.
(audience laughter) I might be 83-- but still, a chance.
But then my body started telling a different story.
After a few health scares, a long recovery from a surgery, I had, for the first time since before our babies were born, time to rest and reflect and to sit with some uncomfortable truths, like the fact that we don't always get a long life.
And that question, was this how I wanted to live?
Apparently, I must have shared that whole "I'll just date in my 80s" plan with my then-husband.
Because he said to me, "Sarah, "I'm not really comfortable with us living our lives together with you just waiting for me to die."
(audience laughter) But coming out more fully was terrifying.
I was afraid that we'd blow up our marriage, our family, our whole world and that I might still end up alone.
But our biggest fear was about our kids.
Their dad and I were both children of divorce.
We knew what that pain was like.
We did not want that for our kids.
So many nights after the kids were asleep, we took turns crying in our separate bedrooms with a shared wall.
Hearing him in pain would send me spiraling into self-loathing.
And on more than one occasion, he'd come and find me and say, "Don't do that to yourself.
"Don't go there.
Who you are is beautiful, just as you are."
We were determined to find a way forward, to be the parents we wanted to be.
To somehow stay friends while giving each other room to grow.
So as we continued to release the marriage, we moved into that new house, our duplex.
Whoo hoo!
I lived upstairs, he lived downstairs, and the kids lived everywhere.
They had bedrooms on both floors.
And although our very detailed parenting plan said that when one parent was the "on grownup," the other parent was free to do as they wished, in reality, those kids were everywhere all the time.
And it took time for us all to adjust.
The apartments had identical floor plans, so to help the kids out, we put everyday items in the same locations on both floors.
We may have done this a little too well.
For months after we moved in, our younger kid would look up from what they were doing and ask, "What floor am I on right now?"
(audience laughter) I had no idea how emotionally hard it would be for the adults to live in such close proximity.
Dating, for example.
He had no trouble at all, he was a catch, he found lots of people to date.
I remember one afternoon, I felt so envious.
He was heading out to stay with somebody he was dating, and he was going to go directly from her house to work the next morning.
And he had packed this teeny, tiny little overnight bag.
And I looked at that small bag, and I looked down at his enormous size 13 sneakers, and I thought, "Do I remind him to pack his work shoes?"
Because they're not in that bag.
No, that's not my job anymore.
But then I did say something, because I thought maybe that's what a good friend would do.
And this was just one of many moments where we had to renegotiate who we were to each other.
Dating for me, I found it really challenging to meet other single gay women at my stage of life.
I went out once for sushi with a woman who ordered sake.
We chatted for a bit about the food, but when the food ran out, so did the conversation.
I learned, this is why you're supposed to go out for coffee first.
But there I sat, staring at an empty plate, willing the waiter to come bring the check.
But she still had lots of sake left.
She got so tipsy and so talkative that she forgot to stop pouring even when her cup was full.
She just sat there talking and pouring (chuckles) and pouring and flooding the whole table with sake.
There were other surprises, too, with duplex living.
We thought we bought a house where sound wouldn't travel much.
It was an old house, built like a tank, mostly soundproof.
"Mostly" being the key word.
The only weak spots were between our bedrooms.
You can imagine my surprise, lying in bed with earplugs, a pillow over my head, listening to the same snoring that had kept me awake for all those years and thinking, "This is just wrong."
But we were in it for the long haul.
And while it was excruciating for the adults at times, the kids benefited.
When they were about eight and 11 years old, they had friends whose parents were going through these horrible, messy divorces.
And I think it was the first time that our kids realized their experience of divorce wasn't everybody's reality, that our family looked different.
And while we never expected it, they thanked us for what we had created, which felt really good.
But the real proof was watching them grow up, knowing that they are loved exactly as they are for who they are, and seeing them accept themselves and seeing that confidence carry them into adulthood.
That's when I knew the hard choices had been the right ones.
Today, our kids are in their early 20s, they have four happy parents who finally live in two separate houses.
(laughter) And it did all work out.
Not because it was easy, not because we did it perfectly.
It worked out because we chose truth and love; even when it was terrifying.
The volcano did erupt.
But instead of destroying everything, it cleared the ground for love to bloom.
Thank you.
(cheers and applause) ♪ ♪ LUCAS: My name is Quentin Lucas.
I was originally born in Frankfurt, Germany, son of a soldier in the army, and I grew up in Boston.
And I'm a professional writer.
So writing has been part of your life for quite some time.
LUCAS: Yes.
- Can you talk to me about how it became part of your life?
In the beginning, writing was really a way of healing.
What I found as a teenager going through teenage stuff, is my notebook was my safe place.
I could write there, I could say whatever I wanted to say, wouldn't get in trouble, I wouldn't get judged.
And the great thing was, sometimes I can go back to that notebook, reread something I'd forgotten I wrote and see something new about myself.
It was really a world of self-discovery.
OKOKON: Mm.
- And that became kind of a foundation for my launch into other types of writing.
So what kinds of themes do you find yourself kind of most drawn to in your writing?
I think the theme that stands out for me as the most important is the tension between fear and love for a character.
For me personally, I find that to be... ...the most interesting human element that helps me write stories that connect with other people.
Often it's said in storytelling, the advice is given to write from the scar and not from the active wound.
LUCAS: Mm-hmm.
- Can you talk about what role that advice plays for you?
When I sit down, let's say, before a blank page, I have to ask myself that question.
Is this a wound or is this a scar?
Because whatever I put on a page or from the stage, it's going out to the world.
And again, the world can do with it whatever they want.
OKOKON: Mm-hmm.
- And so, I caution my students, please be safe with yourself.
Your stories are beautiful, the act of telling the story is in fact a heroic act.
But is this a wound or is this a scar?
Because I don't think you want the world playing with your wounds that aren't finished healing yet.
My father was a Vietnam War vet, which fascinated me as a boy, in part because he'd never talk about it.
Maybe it was too difficult for him, or maybe he wanted to protect me, but I needed to understand.
So I wrote my own version of events, just a paragraph from a second grader, thinking about his father being in the army, fighting in a war and probably being afraid.
But I ended the story with everything being okay, because Dad was home now.
And now that story from my childhood reminds me why now, as an adult, I still use storytelling to try to understand.
15 years later, after writing that award-winning story, it's 2003.
Now, I'm the son of a war vet during a time of war, and a college student with ambitions of becoming a writer.
And there was still something about my father that I needed to understand.
I enlisted in the army to be a military journalist.
But when my recruiter told me that those positions were filled, he also told me that I'd done so well on the test, that I could have almost any job that was available.
I had grown up in a neighborhood that offered the threat of gunfire for free.
(laughter) So why not sign up and get a bonus check as well?
My only deal breaker was that I had already been around enough death to know that I would not take a job where I had to kill people.
My recruiter helped me find a job where I wouldn't have to kill people.
Cavalry Scout.
Basic training in Fort Knox, Kentucky, was a months-long stretch of holding a rifle with frozen hands, boots full of cold rainwater and screaming drill sergeants.
Not long after graduating from basic and becoming a Cavalry Scout, I was telling my sergeant that there was some mistake.
I'd never intended to sign up for a job that was focused on combat killing.
I'd already had one emotional breakdown during basic training where I'd met other soldiers who'd experienced this same... ...mistake.
My sergeant seemed to understand.
He'd killed people in Iraq, but knew that most people didn't want to kill anyone.
But the army had a mission to accomplish.
A mission which I was not ready for.
I knew that I had told that recruiter I would not kill people, and that he heard me, he'd said as much.
But the army had won.
They got me.
And I was squeezed by the irony.
I'd fled a world where people rotted in prison for killing people, for a world where I now face rotting in prison for not killing people.
But... my conscientious objector application was being considered.
I knew this because tensions had reached such a height, that the army eventually told me that I was an insubordinate, disrespectful "leadership challenge" and even for the army, too damn angry.
(audience chuckling) (audience laughing) But if I calmed down, they would take my conscientious objector application from the bottom of the pile and give it real consideration.
I did not calm down.
Until one day we were training.
I was learning how to treat a suburb like a battlefield.
And I was on a break reading a book, "Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave," and happened upon a scene where Douglass gets into a fist fight with a slave breaker, wins, and then decides that nobody will ever touch him again without getting touched back.
I don't know what any of you have read about American slavery.
This was a self-imposed death sentence.
But it was also a choice.
And if Douglass could choose while enslaved, then certainly I could choose while in the army.
So I decided that I was simply choosing not to kill people.
That's all.
It's my small, simple truth.
And as a result, my days in the army were calmer, even though a court martial now felt inevitable.
During my court martial, a soldier testified that our captain had told him he was never considering any conscientious objector applications.
My lawyer, he told me I should have joined the Air Force.
(laughter) They would have just given me a different job.
I was found guilty and sentenced to Fort Sill, Oklahoma's medium security prison for 13 months.
I could only hear my father sobbing as he was behind me while I was being handcuffed and escorted away.
Sometimes prison felt like the hardest thing I'd ever do.
Other times, my community gave me strength.
Family visited, friends wrote.
On occasion, even strangers wrote.
One time I received a postcard from someone in France who had the poetry in him to write me, "Thank you for taking a step toward a world without war."
I was confused by the words, I felt unworthy of them.
But then a letter from Germany, Japan, Texas, California, England, India, a classroom in New York.
I couldn't respond to all the stories people kept sharing with me from around the world.
My mother had told Amnesty International why I was in prison.
Amnesty International told everyone else.
My father's gone now.
But now having my own military experience, I do understand him better.
A story can be a mirror and a window.
A glimpse into someone's life, and a reflection into my own, which is why I craved his stories so much.
Seeing more of him was a way to see more of me.
But some stories are really hard to tell.
I don't know if I could tell a child a Vietnam War story.
But now, like my father, I also have a child who wants all of my stories, including the one I just told you.
And I'm going to do it.
I'm going to tell the story because I want to exist in my daughter's life in any way I can, like my father, who now exists in my life as one of my most precious and important stories.
Thank you.
(cheers and applause) ♪ ♪ SEMPLE: My name is Christina Semple, born and raised in Atlanta, Georgia.
I am a therapist, I am a professor and also an end of life doula.
So I've heard that this is your first time sort of approaching storytelling in this way.
SEMPLE: Yes, yes.
What drew you to this?
Oh, wow, so this opportunity came to me, I was actually attending a support group for Black women who have experienced cancer.
And one of the facilitators talked about the theme for that night was how to share your story.
And it was a very profound night because I have always felt like my cancer journey isn't unique or it wasn't big enough, or I wasn't devastated enough as I hear, and I would compare my stories to other women.
And this amazing facilitator just looked me square in the eyes and said, "Your story matters.
People need to hear your voice."
And so I just started searching for places to share my story, to find community, people who can learn from me, and who I can learn from their experiences.
And that's how I came across "Stories from the Stage."
OKOKON: That's beautiful.
So what has this experience been like?
What has it been like for you to craft and create this story to tell?
Oh, it's been amazing.
It has absolutely been one of the most surprisingly challenging experiences of my life, because this story isn't a story.
It is my lived experience.
It is still my life.
It is still unfolding.
And so it has forced me to sort of reconcile as best as possible my experiences with my family, my relationships with my family, my grief.
Right, and that has been challenging, but the growth that I've experienced and the way I communicate my story and with my family has completely changed.
And that change wouldn't have happened without this opportunity.
My mother and I both had cancer at the same time.
But only one of us knew that.
There was no particular moment when I decided not to tell my family I had cancer.
The truth just always lingered in the background.
But sometime between late August, when my doctor called to say, "Christina, we found something, and it's not good."
And a few weeks later, when I learned my mom had survived her cancer surgery, that I realized something's real.
My mom had just survived her cancer surgery.
But I wasn't so sure that I would survive mine.
The call from my doctor came while I was still at work.
I told no one and did nothing for about 30 minutes.
I just sat silently in my office.
And then I decided to go outside and sit on the stoop.
I was watching people walk by, laughing, talking, life happening in front of me.
But this time, it was almost in slow motion.
I think I just needed the reminder that I wasn't dead yet.
Then I called my boyfriend, Joseph to tell him, "Let's just keep it between us."
Because this was my illness, and I needed to decide when and how it entered the world.
So I made a list of who I would tell, when and how: my best friends, Joe's sisters, and then was my employer.
Because being a therapist, I knew changes to my appearance, my memory, my performance, would not go unnoticed.
But my family?
They never even made the list.
Weeks later, everything changed.
Because our mom died.
And overnight, I became the executor of her estate.
The grief was real, yes, but responsibility took over.
I told myself I have one job to do.
Handle the estate exactly as she wanted.
So my diagnosis became secondary.
A couple days after the funeral, I decided to spend the night with my girlfriends.
And they allowed me to pretend for just one night that my mommy wasn't dead and I didn't have cancer.
We laughed, they cried, and I ate way too much.
And it was amazing.
But the next day, as I was pulling into the driveway of our family home, something just felt off.
There was this pit in my stomach, And the hair in the back of my neck stood up.
And like, somehow, even the house looked different from the outside.
I don't know, I thought it was my grief, but now I know it was my intuition telling me... ...I'm about to walk into a war zone.
Seated at the large, wooden dining room table were my twin brothers.
The one to my right, he had cared for both our mother and father until they died in that same house.
The brother across from me was wound tight.
His eyes and his words were rigid.
Between us on the table was a copy of our mother's will.
There were pages that were bent, words were circled, things were highlighted.
And that's when I knew... ...all hell was about to break loose.
What followed next wasn't a conversation, it felt like an ambush.
My brother across from me hurled accusations that I was manipulating our mother to try and take the estate.
I tried to answer him, I tried to do what our mother wanted me to do.
But it turned dark and it turned ugly.
And it broke us.
I was wearing our mother's wedding ring.
The one she wanted him to have, yes, but I just needed to feel her close to me for a few more days.
In the heat of the moment, I just ripped it off my finger and I slammed it on the table in front of him.
And I peeled off.
Shaking and nauseous, I got into my car and I called my Joseph to tell him what happened.
And then when we got off the phone, the conversation, the fight was going over in my head like a vicious loop.
What I said, what he said, what happened in our family's house.
But that loop was broken by a wave of... ...relief.
Thank God I didn't tell them about my cancer.
Because apparently, now I was at war.
I couldn't let the enemy know anything that could be perceived as a weakness.
Even if that enemy was my own brother.
Six months later, right before radiation began, I decided to tell my brothers.
But not because I was ready, only because if something happened, I didn't want them to find out second hand.
My one brother, the peaceful one, he just said, "Tina, are you okay?
What does this mean?
What do you need?"
He never questioned why I waited to tell the family.
He just accepted that was the way his self-contained sister was.
But the other brother, the one that accused me?
Completely unraveled.
He mumbled something, and hung up the phone, because it hit him all at once.
That the moment he was attacking my character, I had cancer attacking my breast.
There were moments when I was first diagnosed that I wish my brothers would have known.
The care that they could have provided would have somehow softened the blow of my cancer journey.
And yet there's two different truths with each brother.
With the one that accused me, I know I made the right choice.
I know now that he just didn't know what an executor does or how will functions.
But that doesn't soften the blow for me.
With the other brother... ...I know I made the wrong choice.
I just assumed that the grief from our mother would make my diagnosis too much for him.
I underestimated him.
He and I are closer now.
But with that closeness brings a quiet sort of guilt for me.
And it reminds me that next time, I will trust him.
I will trust us, with the truth, in real time.
Looking back, I see now that I was a daughter who had just become an orphan, a sister dragged into a fight, and a cancer patient trying not to die.
And I still think about the 101 choices I could have made differently.
But one thing I know to be true, is that I did the best that I could under the worst of circumstances.
Thank you.
(cheers and applause) ♪ ♪
Video has Closed Captions
Preview: S10 Ep6 | 30s | Telling the truth can set us free, but it rarely comes without consequences. (30s)
Providing Support for PBS.org
Learn Moreabout PBS online sponsorship
New Episode- Arts and Music

Innovative musicians from every genre perform live in the longest-running music series.
New Episode- Arts and Music

Intimate portraits of six of the most influential and celebrated classical music artists.
New Episode

New Season

New Episode
New Episode

Recently Added
Support for PBS provided by:
Stories from the Stage is a collaboration of WORLD and GBH.